Red, Blue or Indifferent: The Election Changed Fundraising

September 01, 2017 - by Tiffany Neill



November 8, 2016 marked a turning point in fundraising in the United States. The unanticipated outcome of the presidential election resulted in a surge in donors. Many organizations adjusted fundraising strategies and are now asking, “what’s next.”

A panel of experts from the Association of Direct Response Fundraising Counsel aimed to answer that question during the 2017 DMA Nonprofit Conference in Chicago in a session titled “Crystal Ball: Whether Yours is Red or Blue, We Have Something for You.” Jennifer Mercer of Thrive Marketing Group, John Mini of John Mini Consulting, Jack Doyle of Amergent and Tiffany Neill of Lautman Maska Neill & Company, shared insights about the factors impacting donor behavior in the post-election world.

The election fell when the demographic and psychographic composition of donors was already shifting. Both “rage donating” and “celebration donating” yielded large numbers of new donors to some organizations, but overall giving remained flat. With more donors aged 85 and older than ever before, there was also an increase in the percentage of younger people giving. Regardless of age, all donors are comfortable with technology and expect the tools used by nonprofits to be easy to use, and work ever time.

The new administration is likely to make changes to the tax structure that will have a dramatic impact on nonprofits. It is unclear whether the charitable deduction will remain as is, or if it will be capped or eliminated. The December 31 deadline for giving might become meaningless, and many savvy donors are front-loading giving to take advantage of current tax code. Many donors are choosing to do this by funding Donor Advised Funds, and charities are finding new ways to solicit these gifts.

The unexpected election results have resulted in charities asking donors to take advocacy positions for the first time. For example, health organizations who previously raised money for research or patient care encouraged donors to call Congress about proposed changes to the Affordable Care Act. And the new messages resonate with donors. Likewise, religious organizations asked donors to take stands on immigration, inclusion and unity, replacing traditional messages.

Finally, progressive advocacy organizations who acquired a lot of new donors in the days after the election are working hard to keep donors engaged. Organizations saw a surge in new donors coming online, as well as new monthly donors, and are using an array of communications (online, offline, text, and social) to keep them engaged. The good news is that organizations are seeing donor activation rates remain high and monthly donors are remaining loyal after six months at a higher rate than seen before the election.

The bottom line from the panel is to continue to communicate to donors through all channels with current, authentic messages that reflects the reality of the post-election world.


Industry Articles

March 2021

When a Woman Is “The First,” Can She Also Be “The Best”?

June 2020

Recurring Gifts — If You Don't Ask, You Won't Recieve

March 2020

DMAW WEBINAR: Fundraising in the Middle of a Pandemic

June 2018

We entered muggles. We left magicians.

June 2018

The Magic Your Organization Needs

April 2018

5 Sure-fire Ways to Increase Response Rates

July 2017

It’s July: Do You Know Where Your 2018 Direct Response Budget Is?

June 2017

7 Ideas For Multi-Channel Break-Throughs

November 2016

8 Years of Uncertainty is Enough

September 2016

Direct Mail Premiums: Pros and Cons From a Former Pro

August 2016

Beyond Email Copy

July 2016

Podcast on On Direct Response Fundraising – with guest Lisa Maska

June 2016

Giving USA: 2015 Was America’s Most-Generous Year Ever

May 2016

Philanthropy: Make Your Mother Proud

July 2015

Fundriaisng Day in New York City

June 2015

Giving USA: Americans Donated an Estimated $358.38 Billion to Charity in 2014; Most in Report’s 60-year History

April 2015

Taget Analytics | donorCentrics™ Index of Direct Marketing Fundraising 2014 Results

March 2015

Communication is Key to Saving Money

February 2015

The 2014 Charitable Giving Report

February 2015

Obama Budget Again Calls for Limit to Charitable Deduction

November 2014

Charitable Giving: How to evaluate and support good causes

November 2014

Member Spotlight

September 2014

The Science Of A Donor Acquisition Package

July 2014

Consider the Environment. Print this.

July 2014

"Pink Slips" Win Big At MAXI Awards

June 2014

Giving USA 2014 Highlights

May 2014

Education Opportunities for Non-Profit Executives

March 2014

Member Spotlight: Emerging Leader

February 2014

Learning From MAXI Excellence

September 2013

30 Brilliant Bits of Online Fundraising Wisdom from the Experts

August 2013

Building a Stronger Bridge: Conference Volunteer, Tiffany Neill Looks Ahead

June 2013

Non-Profit Fundraising and Marketing in a Multi-Channel World

June 2013

Invest in Marketing and Fundraising to Encourage Innovation

November 2012

Direct Response: Not So ‘Direct’ Anymore?